The Short Answer

Buying usually comes out ahead only if you stay put for a long time, often 10 years or more at today's interest rates. It also depends on rents in your area being high compared with home prices. If you might move within five to seven years, renting is usually the cheaper choice, even though you build no equity.

"Renting is throwing money away" leaves out half the picture. Owners have unrecoverable costs too: mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance, and the cost of buying and selling. The fair question is which path leaves you with more money at the end.

Start With the 5% Rule

A widely used rule of thumb puts the yearly unrecoverable cost of owning at about 5% of the home's price. That's roughly 1% for property tax, 1% for maintenance, and 3% for the cost of your money (mortgage interest, plus what your down payment could have earned elsewhere).

Break-even monthly rent ≈ Home Price × 5% ÷ 12

For a $400,000 home, that works out to about $1,667 a month. If you can rent a comparable place for less, renting is likely the better deal. If comparable rent is well above it, buying starts to make sense.

One caveat: the 3% cost of money assumes low interest rates. With mortgage rates in the 6% to 7% range, our numbers below put the line closer to 6% of the home's price, or about $2,000 a month for a $400,000 home.

A Side-by-Side Example

These are the default numbers in our rent vs. buy calculator: $2,000/month rent rising 3% a year, versus buying a $400,000 home with 10% down at 6.5% for 30 years, 1.2% property tax, $1,500/year insurance, 1% maintenance, and 3% annual appreciation. You can load them and follow along.

In the first month, owning costs $3,134: $2,275 for principal and interest, $400 property tax, $125 insurance, and $333 maintenance. Only about $325 of that is principal, the part that builds equity. The other $2,808 is gone, just like rent. In the early years, an owner's unrecoverable costs are higher than the $2,000 rent.

The Simple Comparison

Most quick comparisons line up total rent paid against the net cost of buying: everything you paid as an owner, minus the equity you'd walk away with. By that measure, buying in this example is ahead by about $26,000 after 5 years and $91,000 after 10.

That simple version leaves out three things that matter a lot:

  • Closing costs when you buy: typically 2% to 5% of the price. We'll use 3%, or $12,000.
  • Selling costs when you leave: agent commissions, legal fees, and transfer costs often add up to 5% to 7% of the sale price. We'll use 6%.
  • What the renter does with the cash: the renter keeps the $52,000 down payment and closing costs, plus the roughly $1,100 a month they don't spend on owning. Invested at 6% a year, that money grows too.

The Full Comparison

Here is the same example with those three costs included. This full version is what our calculator shows by default. To see the simple version, set closing costs, selling costs, and investment return to 0. The table shows how much more money the buyer ends up with than the renter: the buyer's home value after selling costs and paying off the loan, minus the renter's investment balance.

Years in the Home Simple Comparison Full Comparison
3 yearsBuying +$11,000Renting +$41,000
5 yearsBuying +$26,000Renting +$42,000
10 yearsBuying +$91,000Renting +$38,000
15 yearsBuying +$204,000Renting +$16,000
20 yearsBuying +$375,000Buying +$30,000
30 yearsBuying +$945,000Buying +$252,000

Once you count all the costs, buying doesn't pull ahead until about year 18 in this example. Over a lifetime it still wins, and by a lot. But if you move every few years, the cost of buying and selling each time can cost you more than the equity you build.

The full comparison assumes the renter actually invests the difference every month. If that money gets spent instead, buying wins sooner. A mortgage works as forced savings, and for many people that's a real advantage.

What Tips the Balance

Two inputs move the answer more than anything else. Both use the full comparison above.

  • Rent compared with the price. At $1,500 rent, renting is ahead by about $130,000 after 10 years. At $2,500 rent, buying is ahead by about $55,000 after 10 years and breaks even around year 6.
  • Home appreciation. Over 10 years, 1% a year leaves renting ahead by about $128,000. At 5% a year, buying is ahead by about $69,000. That's why an optimistic appreciation guess can make almost any purchase look good.

Interest rates matter too. A lower rate shrinks the biggest unrecoverable cost of owning. Use our mortgage calculator to see how much of your payment goes to interest at the rate you're quoted.

When Renting Wins

  • You expect to move within about 7 years.
  • Comparable rent is below roughly 5% to 6% of the home's price per year.
  • Buying would empty your emergency fund.
  • Home prices in your area are flat or falling.

When Buying Wins

  • You plan to stay 10 years or more.
  • Local rents are high and rising compared with home prices.
  • You can make the down payment and still keep cash reserves.
  • You'd rather have the stability and control of owning, and you know you wouldn't invest the money otherwise.

Before you go further, check what you can actually afford. Our guide to how much house you can afford walks through the lender's math.

How to Run Your Own Numbers

  1. Find the monthly rent for a place comparable to the home you'd buy: same area, size, and condition.
  2. Apply the 5% rule: home price × 5% ÷ 12. If rent is well below that, renting probably wins; well above, buying probably wins.
  3. Enter your real numbers in the rent vs. buy calculator and compare over 5, 10, and 20 years.
  4. Set realistic closing costs, selling costs, and an investment return you'd actually earn. Use 0% for the return if you wouldn't invest the money you save by renting.
  5. Be honest about how long you'll stay. That single number matters more than any other input.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is rent really money thrown away?
No more than mortgage interest is. Rent buys you a place to live, and so do interest, property tax, insurance, and maintenance. In the example above, an owner's unrecoverable costs in year one are about $2,800 a month, compared with $2,000 in rent. What owning adds is equity, and it takes years to outweigh the extra costs.

How many years do I need to stay for buying to make sense?
It depends on rent, price, and rates. In our example it's about 18 years once all costs are counted. If rent is high compared with the price, it can be as short as 5 or 6. If rent is low compared with the price, buying may never catch up.

Is the 5% rule still accurate with higher interest rates?
It's a starting point. The 3% cost-of-money piece was set when rates were lower. With mortgage rates around 6% to 7%, about 6% of the home's price is a more realistic break-even line for annual rent.

What return should I assume if I rent and invest the difference?
We used 6% a year, a reasonable long-run assumption for a diversified, stock-heavy portfolio. Returns aren't guaranteed and vary year to year. A more conservative 4% to 5% shortens the time buying needs to pull ahead. Our guide to compound growth with monthly contributions shows how much that rate matters.

Does the calculator include closing and selling costs?
Yes. The rent vs. buy calculator includes closing costs, selling costs, and the investment return on money a renter doesn't put into a house. It defaults to 3%, 6%, and 6%. Change them to fit your market and your plans.